February 23–25, 2023 Le Locle & La Chaux-de-Fonds, Switzerland — 47.0999° N, 6.7928° E EDAR Course AR-669

Index / PhD Notes / PHD–08

Gino Baldi

Founding — A Targeted Reading of Industrial Heritage

PHD–08 Politecnico di Milano Field Notes — Feb 2023

Founding is the verb, the action through which the theme of the workshop is interpreted and critically read. As part of the Urban Regeneration and Industrial Heritage Workshop, it was possible to investigate a declination of the term “Foundation” from a terminological point of view, making it a tool for a targeted reading of the industrial heritage of the cities of Le Locle and La Chaux-de-Fonds (CH).

The project incipit starts from the concept of foundation, trying to analyse it from different points of view. The idea of foundation can have different declinations and meanings depending on the context in which it is placed. The term “foundation” contains an intrinsic ambiguity: on the one hand the cultural, symbolic theme, the act of initiation of an organisation, aggregation or society; on the other hand, in purely architectural terms, the foundation is a structural, physical, material component capable of performing the translation from idea to construction. It is an apparent decoupling of the same term, with tangible and intangible, material and immaterial, visible and invisible qualities.

Field notes by Gino Baldi, plate 1
Plate 01 — field notebook, Gino Baldi
Field notes by Gino Baldi, plate 2
Plate 02 — field notebook, Gino Baldi
§ 02

The research moved in search of a point of contact within the working group, through a multicultural and interdisciplinary approach. On the one hand, the social aspect that puts people at the centre; the functions that can reactivate the place, through cultural networks and the place where they can be located, the type of space that identifies them from an architectural point of view. The collaboration between the different figures takes place around a table, as in a professional job or a competition, highlighting the qualities of the different points of view. A physical and conceptual table, i.e. a plan for sharing different cultures and approaches to the same place, and on the other hand the actual discussion and confrontation that took place during the inspection. In particular, it was possible to move within the territory of Le Chaux de Founds and Le Locle, through a cognitive exploration that was based on an initial phase of critical observation of the territory, with drawings, notes and photographic documentation of relevant and/or particular conditions of the territory. In particular, we started from the observation of the place, in its spaces, in its morphological conformation from the point of view of architectural elements. The presence of different levels in the city, unevenness, sloping roads, a decisive topography in the area. These are characters that immediately brought attention to the ground level, the relationship with the ground, the different horizontal connections of the territory to be inhabited. In fact, the territory is occupied at an urban level in a rational, linear way, with a regular sequence of buildings, which however interface with a topography and territory with steep slopes. The question around which the observation of the ground line revolves is how this condition can become a participant and motor for a reuse of the territory. The methodology of investigation is diversified around common themes. The theme of the foundation, in its inherent ambiguity, leads to immaterial investigations through interviews and material through the location of relevant associations and photographic reports of where these are located. The aim is to merge the two different components that identify the term foundation into a strategic tool for reactivating disused spaces and associations that are as potential as they are hidden.

Research was carried out through a network system, focusing on the people who inhabit the spaces, discovering a condition of invisibility not linked to a physical dimension, but of isolation. These are hidden potentials, to be found in the corners of abandoned industrial spaces or on the main floors of former workers' housing. Small neighbourhood associations, linked to the local community, were first identified in Le Locle and in Le Chaux de Fonds, such as ateliers for artists (X personnes) or cultural areas of industrial reuse (Centren d'art contemporain) or spontaneous appropriation of industrial spaces, renewing them through new soil (Skatepark N'Sun). All of these identify small associations, places that can be identified by mistake or in a very targeted way. Therein lies their identity and invisible quality. They encapsulate many of the identity aspects of these places, which are not easy to access. For example, in the case of X personnes, Atelier for artistic spaces, it is located in an industrial building that retains floors, columns and continuity of space and lighting typical of the industrial rationality with which they were built. But the term 'Foundation' has further meanings.

Leon Battista Alberti, in his famous treatise 'De re Aedificatoria', makes a clear distinction between the terms 'foundation' and 'founding'. (2) In particular, the term 'foundation', from the Latin 'fondare', does not identify a component of the construction, but the place where the construction is located. To found is to go deep, it is excavation work, to find the solid layer on which the structure rests. In this sense, it is evident how the role of the foundation is linked to the place and thus to the topography. The rationality of the arrangement of the different architectural bodies clashes with a difficulty of the ground, triggering an identity landscape of Le Chaux de Founds and Le Locle. If the arrangement of these volumes seeks maximum efficiency in terms of spatial illumination, movement and ease of development as identified in Charles Henri Junod's plan, it is interesting to identify how these principles do not apply in a neutral and regular territory, but from a strong topographical identity and a terrain with a wide variety of soils, albeit in a relatively small area. In fact, the territory is characterised by different scenarios that manage to connect marshy valley floor areas with mountain slopes of a calcareous nature. It is therefore interesting to trace, catalogue and highlight the ways in which rational principles connect such an irregular territory. The 'spy' of these declinations can be found in the singular ways in which the buildings relate to the terrain, ways in which the building attaches itself to the ground.

§ 03

According to Alois Diethelm, the contact between the building and the ground does not only determine the transfer of loads, in a constructive way, but also the interface with the topography of the site, in a relationship that is not only structural, but also compositional, in relation to form. (3) In fact, architecture is inscribed into the topographical structure of the landscape through its formal relationship. (4) The relationship with the land becomes a sense of belonging and appropriation of a place; not just a technical, geological, morphological aspect, but a true design strategy. (5) It can appear as an adaptation, complement, exaggeration, or simply modification or by contrast negation of the soil. (4)

In the essay "Anchoring" Steven Holl emphasises how the building is intertwined with the experience of a place.(6) The site of a building is more than just an element of its conception; they are their physical and metaphysical foundations. Architecture is an extension, a modification that establishes meanings relative to the place it appropriates. Thus the ground line that constantly changes and identifies the morphology of the two cities becomes a spy, a first clue to certain design conditions. The foundations thus become a "circumstantial paradigm" (7) for research, an element commonly not analysed, but capable of highlighting very relevant characters in the study and reading of the building. Particularly in the Le Locle area, as in Le Chaux de Fonds, the various buildings that dot the landscape and are repeated in a more or less homogeneous manner throughout the territory, find clear moments of alteration in the low level of the buildings. Probable alterations of modern times, they break with the tradition and local character of the buildings to introduce a new language, through metal materials, glass ribbons that mark the clear public character of the ground floor. This generates a point of rupture in some buildings, a division into two, a below and an above, a visible and an invisible.

Field notes by Gino Baldi, section 03, plate 1
§ 03 · Plate 01 — Gino Baldi
Field notes by Gino Baldi, section 03, plate 2
§ 03 · Plate 02 — Gino Baldi
§ 04

Above local character, history, heritage, identity; below transition, reuse, transformation, adaptation. In between, the possibility of a compromise, a point of contact to renew the territory. Research through associations has revealed realities hidden in the anonymity of local architectural conditions. A door, steps, platforms that connect the unevenness of the ground, shop windows, are elements that make up the atmosphere of these places. Anonymous, but with the identity qualities of the place and concealing fundamental associations of the territory in its local dimension. The three images in the abaco are intended to evoke the potential of constructing a space with a few elements as done in Luigi Ghirri's photographic collection "Colazione sull'erba" of 1972-74. Important verbal information was gathered from these places for a social aspect in contrast to the anonymity of the architectural object within which they are contained. All these spaces were catalogued photographically and compared in an abacus of comparison, recalling the method used by Bernd and Hilla Becher in the context of industrial buildings, generating a critical comparison.

Naturally, this is carried out within the timeframe of the workshop and therefore identifies itself in a quick scan, an implementable system, which exploits the potential of the obvious and immediately noticeable characters, based on the impression and observation given by the survey and visit of the areas. It is a systemisation of a method of observation that intersects social, functional and typological aspects of the city. A conceptual and mental section of the city is made, analysing the resulting content, intersecting the different data found. An abacus is thus generated, of images placed in relation. In particular, on the vertical axis, the characters linked to the disciplinary fields of investigation are put in order: architecture, people and networks. On the vertical axis a possible mix of new uses of spaces is generated, superimposing identity places, architectural spaces on display and hidden spaces in a single element. A cataloguing of images is generated in the ground connection, comparing and triggering a critical analysis between spaces with a public or communicative vocation in contrast to the typological identities of the places, ground connection of the spaces of associations hiding their qualities in a facade anonymity and finally the invisible qualities of these associations. The intention is not to give an answer, but to pose questions, capable of suggesting some possible answers.

Field notes by Gino Baldi, section 04, plate 1
§ 04 · Plate 01 — Gino Baldi
Field notes by Gino Baldi, section 04, plate 2
§ 04 · Plate 02 — Gino Baldi